# Session 0014.0 — Transcript

> App: dev-claude-plugin
> Start: 2026-06-04T06-21 (PST)
> End: 2026-06-04T07-04 (PST)
> Type: coding
> Goal: Build `wgl-dev-plugin-review-feedback` — the review half of the
> plugin-feedback loop: read the `feedback/` corpus, triage `status:new` notes,
> turn them into plugin changes, advance their status.
> Outcome: **Shipped as plugin v0.13.0.** New skill + two deterministic scripts,
> status-lifecycle docs, README/plugin.json wiring. Merged via PR #7 (merge
> `c3a27a4`). Operator re-installed the plugin at session end.

## Plan

Build `wgl-dev-plugin-review-feedback` — the **review** half of the
plugin-feedback loop, sibling of the `wgl-dev-plugin-feedback` capture skill.

Design decisions (grounded in the existing corpus/capture conventions):

- **Not a gate-lifter; not a tracked session.** Like the capture skill, it's a
  dev-tooling action invoked *within* a coding session (it produces plugin
  changes). Mirrors capture's "What this is NOT".
- **Status lifecycle** (extends `feedback/README.md`, docs-first):
  `new` → `accepted` (valid, deferred) → `done` (shipped); or `new` → `declined`
  (with reason); or `new` → `duplicate` (points at canonical note). `done`
  carries `resolved-version` + `resolved-date` + a `## Resolution` body section.
- **Append-only reconciliation:** the *capture* path stays append-only
  (`record-feedback.sh` never overwrites). The *review* path deliberately edits
  `status` / appends `## Resolution` — but only as part of a reviewed branch→PR
  plugin change (code, not the append-only data path). Note context is never
  rewritten. Documented in `feedback/README.md`.
- **Two deterministic scripts (§4.2):** `list-feedback.sh` (query notes by
  status; default `new`) and `set-feedback-status.sh` (validate + advance a
  note's status in the working tree, stamp resolution metadata). The skill is the
  natural-language triage/judgment layer on top.
- **Operates on the source checkout** (cwd's git root), honoring the
  edit-source-never-deployed-copies policy.

Ship: new skill dir + 2 scripts, `feedback/README.md` lifecycle docs, README
skills-table row, `plugin.json` 0.12.0 → 0.13.0, marketplace/plugin descriptions.
Branch `feat/review-feedback-skill` → PR → merge.

## Pre-session state

- Branch `main`, clean and pushed to `origin/main` at `10b537a` (the prior
  session 0013 / PR #6 merge — `wgl-session-*` rename + `wgl-dev-plugin-feedback`
  capture skill).
- Plugin source version `0.12.0`. The `feedback/` corpus held only its
  `README.md` — **zero notes** captured yet.
- Memory carried an explicit resume pointer for exactly this task
  (`wgl-dev-plugin-review-feedback`, the review half, listed as the open
  follow-up after the 0.12.0 capture skill shipped).

## Turn-by-turn arc

1. **Session gate → classify + claim.** Opening prompt classified as a **coding**
   session (≥90% confidence). Ran `wgl-coding-session-init`: peeked (`--dry-run`,
   no in-flight sessions), claimed **0014** (push `9950bd3`), dropped the local
   `--INPROGRESS` placeholder. Verified clean pushed `main` baseline. Seeded the
   `## Plan` block with the design decisions above.
2. **Read the source material.** Studied the capture side end-to-end:
   `feedback/README.md` (corpus format + frontmatter schema), the
   `wgl-dev-plugin-feedback/SKILL.md`, and `record-feedback.sh` (append-only,
   clone-and-push-to-main, slug collision → `-2`/`-3`). Loaded `writing-skills`
   and inspected `.claude-plugin/{plugin.json,marketplace.json}` (version 0.12.0;
   skills aren't separately registered — they're auto-discovered).
3. **Built the two deterministic scripts first.**
   - `list-feedback.sh` — query notes by status (default `new`; `--all`,
     `--status`, `--repo`/`--dir`); resolves the corpus from cwd's git root; pure
     read; awk-parses frontmatter.
   - `set-feedback-status.sh` — validated status advance in the working tree
     only (never commits/pushes); awk frontmatter surgery rewrites `status:`,
     drops stale `resolved-*` and re-inserts fresh, appends a `## Resolution`
     section.
4. **Tested the scripts against a temp fixture corpus.** Verified: status
   filtering, `--all`, advance-to-`done` with `--resolved-version` + resolution,
   **idempotent re-run** (resolved-* refreshed, not duplicated), **non-terminal
   switch drops resolved-***, invalid-status rejection, missing-note rejection.
   (One combined check command was denied by the sandbox because it included an
   `rm -rf` on the temp dir and an absolute-path probe; re-ran the safe parts
   split out. The `rm -rf` of the fixture was also denied — left for the OS to
   reap; `Bash(rm -rf:*)` is auto-denied in global settings.)
5. **Wrote `SKILL.md`** — the natural-language triage layer: overview, "What this
   is NOT" (mirrors capture), the status-lifecycle summary (pointing at
   `feedback/README.md` as authoritative), a 6-step review-pass workflow, a
   quick-reference table, common mistakes.
6. **Docs-first updates.** Expanded `feedback/README.md` with the full status
   lifecycle and the append-only-vs-review reconciliation. Added the README
   skills-table row, updated the capture row's forward-reference, bumped
   `plugin.json` 0.12.0 → 0.13.0 and its description (two-part loop). Swept the
   capture skill's "future"/"a later … will" forward-references to present tense
   (3 spots) now that the review skill exists; grep-confirmed no stale refs.
7. **Shipped.** Branch `feat/review-feedback-skill`, one commit (`b75c975`),
   pushed. Created the PR via the Gitea API (`wgl-gitea-admin` helper) — the first
   POST returned a transient HTTP 422, the retry created **PR #7**; PATCHed in the
   full body; merged (merge-commit style, `c3a27a4`); synced local `main`,
   deleted the branch local + remote.
8. **Memory + handoff.** Updated the project memory (0.13.0 block, version
   headline, closed the review-feedback follow-up) and the `MEMORY.md` index.
   Offered next-session prompts (lead: the cross-repo digest rename sweep).
9. **Operator re-installed** the plugin (`/reload-plugins`), then asked for a
   next-session prompt, then invoked `/wgl-session-finalize`.

## Cut state (end of session)

- `wiggleverse-dev-claude-plugin` `main` @ `c3a27a4` (PR #7 merge), clean and
  pushed. Feature branch deleted (local + remote).
  - `b75c975` — feat: add wgl-dev-plugin-review-feedback (review half of the
    feedback loop). 7 files, +418/−19.
- Plugin source version **0.13.0**. Operator re-installed at session end, so the
  installed/live copy now includes this skill.
- New: `skills/wgl-dev-plugin-review-feedback/{SKILL.md,scripts/list-feedback.sh,
  scripts/set-feedback-status.sh}` (both scripts `chmod +x`).
- `feedback/` corpus still holds only `README.md` — **no notes yet**, so the loop
  has not been exercised on real data.

## What lands on the operator's plate

- **Nothing blocking.** 0.13.0 is shipped and re-installed.
- The feedback loop is **untested on real data** — the corpus is empty. First
  real `status:new` notes (capture a few via `wgl-dev-plugin-feedback`) would
  shake out any rough edges in `list-feedback.sh` / `set-feedback-status.sh`.
- Still-open backlog (unchanged by this session): the **cross-repo digest rename
  sweep** in the `engineering` repo (stale `wgl-coding-session-init` /
  `wgl-dev-handbook` / `wgl-coding-session-finalize` names in
  `agent-context.md`); the spec-RFC renderer + planner-project seams; the
  Workflow-recording → BDD bug-filing idea.

## Prompt the operator can paste into the next session

```
/goal In the engineering repo, sweep agent-context.md (= ~/.claude/wiggleverse.md) to fix stale skill names: wgl-coding-session-init→wgl-session-coding-init, wgl-dev-handbook→wgl-session-dev-handbook, wgl-coding-session-finalize→wgl-session-finalize. Branch → PR → merge.
```

Alternative (dogfood the thing built this session):

```
/goal Dogfood the plugin-feedback loop end-to-end: capture 2–3 real notes with wgl-dev-plugin-feedback, then run wgl-dev-plugin-review-feedback to triage and advance them on a non-empty corpus — shaking out any rough edges in list-feedback.sh / set-feedback-status.sh.
```