diff --git a/makers-collective-demo/0011/SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--2026-07-07T20-09.md b/makers-collective-demo/0011/SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--2026-07-07T20-09.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c02e07e --- /dev/null +++ b/makers-collective-demo/0011/SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--2026-07-07T20-09.md @@ -0,0 +1,150 @@ +# Session 0011.0 — Transcript + +> App: makers-collective-demo +> Start: 2026-07-07T17-48 (PST) · End: 2026-07-07T20-09 (PST) +> Type: brainstorming (stage 2 continued as tech-design — operator-directed, one claim per session) +> Posture: careful +> Claude-Session: 779f8138-703a-4d08-9d47-22e76fc24ac7 +> Checkout: /Users/benstull/git/wiggleverse.org/wiggleverse/makers-collective-demo--wt-modules (worktree, branch session-0011; removed at finalize after merge) +> Anchor: none — demo repo runs unanchored by design (no Gitea issues for this repo) +> Status: FINALIZED — merged to main at b1ba15b, demo published and verified, spec submitted (status: proposed) + +## Launch prompt + +``` +Let's explore how modules will really work and what the schema will be. We need to create something that scales, is secure, has a moderation/approval system and is simple to author. Where should we start? +``` + +## Plan + +Brainstorm how Hearth **modules** really work — authoring model, scalability, +security, moderation/approval — into the spec's business + product lenses, +then (stage 2, operator-directed mid-session: "Let's do the tech design for +this now to dig deep and come up with a working prototype") author the +engineering lens and land a working prototype of the Studio module surfaces +per the spec↔prototype lockstep. Concurrent SESSION-0010 was live in the main +checkout throughout; this session ran isolated in worktree +`makers-collective-demo--wt-modules` on branch `session-0011`. + +## Pre-state + +- `main` at 60dc906 (spec v0.6.0, Channel + two-feed contract). Spec's module + ground: D4/INV-6 (data not code), INV-7 (version pinning), D26–D29 (filter + lifecycle + Studio), D30–D31 (kinds; author-declared filter capability). + Open: Q4 (engine perf), Q14 (filter registry bar), Q15 (module/filter + overlap), plus no contracts for authoring, capability, approval, views, + writes, or storage. +- SESSION-0010 live and concurrently merging (taglines v0.6.1, The Tube + v0.6.2) — the claim's shared-checkout guard forced this session into its own + worktree before claiming. + +## Arc + +1. **Gate + claim.** Operator chose Brainstorming at the type question. + Claim refused the shared checkout (SESSION-0010 live) → worktree + `--wt-modules`, branch `session-0011`, claimed **0011** stamped + brainstorming/careful. +2. **Stage 1 — brainstorming (spec v0.7.0, D35–D40).** Framing confirmed + (authoring model first), then five checkpoints: **D35** conversation-first + authoring over an always-inspectable, hand-editable manifest; **D36** + expressiveness ceiling = composition + bounded spreadsheet-grade + expressions (no trigger chains; notifications parameterized by the same + expressions); **D37** test loop = sandbox preview + steward-only trial + install, member-facing enable a separate step; **D38** capability = D31 + generalized and typed (defines / reads-by-name / offers; own-types-only + writes; installs narrow; consent sheet renders the declaration verbatim) → + **INV-12**; **D39** registry gate tiered by capability (static validation + always; self-publish own-data; human review for sensitive reads; modules + aren't speech — delist/kill with notice + appeal). **D40** (registry + signals) was adopted provisionally while the operator was AFK and later + REVERSED by the operator at the stage-2 checkpoint: public install counts + for artifacts; INV-11 stays people-scoped. Landed as PUC-25/26/27 + + PUC-11 amendment, §5 Studio surfaces, §6 coherence touches, Q17/Q18. +3. **Stage 2 — tech-design (spec v0.8.0, D41–D46, §6.11).** Operator + checkpoints: **D41** YAML + platform-published versioned JSON Schema; + **D42** restricted CEL profile; **D43** compile-on-pin (resolves Q4). + §6.11 authored: schema outline + worked example, CEL profile, static + validation **V1–V8**, consent-sheet-as-pure-function, execution model, + registry lifecycle states + sensitive-capability policy; Q17 resolved, + Q18 narrowed to review operations. +4. **Working prototype (lockstep).** The Studio Modules tab gained the + **manifest workbench**: editable YAML manifests (Seed Swap + Market + Finder), live V1–V8 validation (subset parser + validator implemented + in-page), consent sheet generated live with per-read narrowing switches, + tier-routed publish + trial-install states, sandbox preview. Verified by + an extracted-core node test harness (grew to 28 tests, all green; + scratchpad-only, not committed). +5. **Operator design probes, each folded in live:** + - *"How is the view defined?"* → **D44** renderer catalog + slot mapping + (closed catalog v1: table/cards/list/calendar/gallery/board; slots map + declared fields; platform owns a11y/theming once; V8). Prototype: + renderer-driven preview — flip `cards` ↔ `table` in the YAML and the + same objects re-render. + - *"Where can I find the yaml schema?"* → it existed only as a name; + authored **`specs/module-manifest.schema.json`** + (`urn:hearth:module-manifest:v1`, draft 2020-12), verified with + PyYAML + jsonschema (both manifests valid; negative controls fail). + - *"How do members add a seed listing / where stored?"* → **D45** derived + forms + bounded field annotations (label/help/choices/required/default — + enums become data); prototype gained a working create path (derived + form renders a select from `choices`; created listings land in the view + or visibly filter out). Storage half answered by §6.2/§6.3. + - *"What's the schema of the postgres store?"* → **D46** one JSONB-spine + `objects` table + defines-validated writes + pin-time partial expression + indexes; companion tables (manifests/installs/vouches/reviews). No + prototype change (no UX surface). + - *"Do we need an API key for an LLM?"* → No: public static page (a key + would be world-readable; §6.3 hard secrets rule), and the working loop + is deliberately deterministic; a live composer would be a server-side + proxy behind the §6.2 AI boundary — future work, not this artifact. +6. **Ship (operator: "commit, merge, publish. And finalize").** Reconciled + with 0010's v0.6.1/v0.6.2 (merge origin/main into session-0011; two spec + conflicts resolved — version header → v0.8.0 keeping all change-log rows; + §5 keeps both sessions' paragraphs; prototype auto-merged; suite green + post-merge). Merged to `main` via a detached temp worktree (main checkout + occupied by 0010) at **b1ba15b**; published via `publish-demo.sh` — origin + sha256 match, HTTP 200 — https://hearth-demo.wiggleverse.org verified. + +## Cut state + +- `main` = b1ba15b: spec **v0.8.0** (D35–D46, INV-12, V1–V8, §6.11.1–.10, + PUC-25/26/27, Q4+Q17 resolved, Q18 narrowed, `status: proposed`) + + `specs/module-manifest.schema.json` + prototype with the working workbench. + Demo live and verified. +- Session worktree removed, branch `session-0011` deleted locally (merged; + remote branch retained). Canonical clone's local `main` left stale at + a8b1cd7 deliberately — it is SESSION-0010's checkout; theirs to fast-forward. +- Spec submitted via submit-spec.sh (`--status proposed`, careful default — + no-op: content already on main). Test harness lives only in the session + scratchpad by design. + +## Deferred decisions + +_Autonomous-mode low-confidence calls the driver made and would have +liked operator input on. Appended as the session runs; surfaced at +finalize. Empty if none._ + +- ~~**Registry trust signals (proposed D40)**~~ — RESOLVED by operator at the + stage-2 checkpoint: **reversed** the provisional call — install counts are + public on registry listings (counts for artifacts, not people; INV-11 stays + people-scoped). D40 amended in the spec. +- **Demo scope for the working prototype (stage 2)** — operator AFK at the + checkpoint; adopted the **full working loop** per the launch instruction + "dig deep and come up with a working prototype": editable YAML manifest + inspector with live validation, live consent-sheet generation, sandbox + preview, tier-routed publish. Implicitly ratified by the operator's + merge-and-publish instruction at review; flag stands for the record. + +## Operator plate + +- Review the shipped spec at leisure (it merged on your instruction with the + whole-document pass compressed): https://git.wiggleverse.org/wiggleverse/makers-collective-demo/src/branch/main/specs/hearth-platform-v1.md +- Q18 (module review operations), Q14 (filter bar — now informed by D39), + Q15 (module/filter overlap — now judgeable against §6.11), Q12/Q13, Q16 + remain the flagged tech-design queue. + +## Next-session prompt + +``` +/goal Complete the Hearth SPEC's remaining engineering lens (tech-design session) for the still-flagged v0.2–v0.6 work — the module system itself is DONE (session 0011, §6.11, D35–D46): biz/* featuring contracts + CatalogFeature lifecycle, BusinessMembership admission/attendance lifecycle (Q12/Q13), the filter manifest shape + disposition contract + profile-scope rendering pipeline + filter registry bar (Q14, informed by D39; module/filter overlap Q15 can now be judged against §6.11), the two-feed contract's Explore recommender (Q16), and module review operations (Q18) — per the §6 version notes in specs/hearth-platform-v1.md +``` diff --git a/makers-collective-demo/0011/SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--INPROGRESS.md b/makers-collective-demo/0011/SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--INPROGRESS.md deleted file mode 100644 index 64164c3..0000000 --- a/makers-collective-demo/0011/SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--INPROGRESS.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,26 +0,0 @@ -# Session 0011.0 — Transcript - -> App: makers-collective-demo -> Start: 2026-07-07T17-48 (PST) -> Type: brainstorming -> Posture: careful -> Claude-Session: 779f8138-703a-4d08-9d47-22e76fc24ac7 -> Checkout: /Users/benstull/git/wiggleverse.org/wiggleverse/makers-collective-demo--wt-modules -> Status: **PLACEHOLDER — claimed at session start; finalized at session end.** -> -> This file reserves session ID 0011 for makers-collective-demo. The driver replaces this -> body with the full transcript and renames the file to its final -> SESSION-0011.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-07-07T17-48--.md form at session end. - -## Launch prompt - -``` -Let's explore how modules will really work and what the schema will be. We need to create something that scales, is secure, has a moderation/approval system and is simple to author. Where should we start? - -``` - -## Deferred decisions - -_Autonomous-mode low-confidence calls the driver made and would have -liked operator input on. Appended as the session runs; surfaced at -finalize. Empty if none._