From 4d14788e74d33e81ab504e1e3236afcf047c1ef8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Ben Stull Date: Fri, 29 May 2026 07:26:13 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] add 0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--2026-05-29T07-23.md + replace placeholder/variant SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--INPROGRESS.md --- ...RIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--2026-05-29T07-23.md | 286 ++++++++++++++++++ ...TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--INPROGRESS.md | 152 ---------- 2 files changed, 286 insertions(+), 152 deletions(-) create mode 100644 0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--2026-05-29T07-23.md delete mode 100644 0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--INPROGRESS.md diff --git a/0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--2026-05-29T07-23.md b/0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--2026-05-29T07-23.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9e7bec4 --- /dev/null +++ b/0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--2026-05-29T07-23.md @@ -0,0 +1,286 @@ +# Session 0041.0 — Transcript + +> Date: 2026-05-29 +> Start: 2026-05-29T05-45 (PST implied) +> End: 2026-05-29T07-23 +> +> Goal: Settle ROADMAP #36 — adopt the meta-only RFC repository topology +> (no per-RFC repos; graduation = in-place state flip), revise the +> rfc-app SPEC + code, fold RFC-0001 back into its meta entry, ship +> rfc-app v0.31.0, deploy to OHM. +> +> Outcome: **#36 SETTLED meta-only. rfc-app v0.31.0 shipped + deployed +> (deploys.id=45, healthy). RFC-0001 folded back to its meta entry +> (repo: null, body restored); wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human archived. OHM +> now has zero per-RFC repos. 375 backend tests green. Follow-on: +> ohm-meta → ohm-content rename tracked under #33.** + +--- + +## Plan / TODO + +- [x] Claim session ID (0041). +- [x] Close stale ohm-meta PR #2 (duplicate "Graduate human" PR). +- [x] Read SPEC §1/§3/§13 + map the rfc-app graduation code surface. +- [x] Operator decisions: settle #36 meta-only; fold RFC-0001 back + (single model); reframe SPEC for the "single content repo" deployer + story + track the ohm-meta→ohm-content rename for #33. +- [x] Revise SPEC §1/§2/§3/§4/§9.8/§13 to meta-only (operator signed off + on the diff). +- [x] rfc-app code: collapse graduation to an in-place flip; re-key the + branch/PR/chat dispatch on meta-residency; remove the per-repo + read path / guards; simplify the bot + GraduateDialog. +- [x] Tests green (full suite 375 passed); frontend builds. +- [x] Bump VERSION + package.json + CHANGELOG (v0.31.0). +- [x] Commit + tag v0.31.0 + push origin + benstull mirror (commit + `0c972c8`, tag `v0.31.0`; rebased over the parallel v0.30.2). +- [x] Bump ohm-rfc pin to v0.31.0 (`69121e6`). +- [x] `flotilla deploy ohm-rfc-app` (deploys.id=45) + verify (healthy). +- [x] RFC-0001 fold-back content migration (ohm-meta PR #8 merged: + body restored, `repo: null`; `wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human` archived). +- [x] Strike ROADMAP #36; capture #33 rename follow-up (`4526f64`). +- [x] Finalize + publish transcript. + +--- + +## Launch prompt + +OHM driver session. Reserve session ID. Context from session 0040.0: +#35 (operator RFC authoring lane) proven; "Informed Consent" super-draft +live; **#36 OPEN + BLOCKING** — decide repo-per-RFC vs. meta-only +(operator leans meta-only); OHM live v0.30.1 (deploys.id=43), rfc-app +main 732b23b; loose end ohm-meta PR #2 (stale graduate-human) open. + +--- + +## Pre-session state + +- OHM live: v0.30.1, healthy (`/api/health` ok). +- rfc-app `main` at `732b23b` (v0.30.1). +- ohm-meta: `human` is **active** (RFC-0001, `repo: + wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human`, graduated 2026-05-26, body stripped to + frontmatter), `informed-consent` is a super-draft. `wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human` + exists with a 22KB `RFC.md`. +- PR #2 was a **duplicate** stale graduation PR (the real graduation + merged 2026-05-26 via another PR); closing it was correct. + +--- + +## Turn-by-turn arc + +### Arc 1 — Orient + operator decisions + +Claimed 0041. Closed ohm-meta PR #2 (the authoring-lane token is +`write:repository`, not `write:issue`, so the explanatory PR comment +got a 403 — closure itself succeeded; **runbook gap noted**: commenting +needs `write:issue` scope). Discovered RFC-0001 is a real graduated +per-repo RFC (22KB RFC.md), which made its fate the pivot for #36. + +Operator decisions (via AskUserQuestion): +1. **Settle #36 meta-only** (full code + deploy, not SPEC-only). +2. **Fold RFC-0001 back** to a single meta-only model (restore body to + the meta entry, archive the repo, delete the per-repo read path) — + rather than grandfathering it as a dual path. +3. **Reframe the SPEC** for the "single content repository" deployer + story (a framework-level win, not just OHM), keep `META_REPO` config + term stable, and **track the concrete `ohm-meta → ohm-content` + rename as a #33 follow-up** (do NOT rename this session). + +### Arc 2 — SPEC revision (signed off) + +Rewrote SPEC §1 (topology: one meta repo, no per-RFC repos, + a boxed +supersession note + deployer-facing "content repository" framing), §2 +(`repo:` always-null, README index, body-migration note), §3 (active = +in-place state), §3.2, §4 (cache/reconciler), §9.8 (the four per-repo +handoff frictions struck through), and §13 in full (retitled "in +place"; §13.2 two-field dialog, no repo name, no open-PR precondition; +§13.3 "The flip" = single open+merge PR, body kept, no transaction/no +rollback, old sequence struck through; §13.4 nothing moves; §13.5 +reversal softened; new §13.6 RFC-0001 fold-back migration record). +Operator approved the diff as the contract. + +### Arc 3 — rfc-app code (meta-only) + +- `api_graduation.py` rewritten: `GraduateBody` drops `repo_name`; + `graduate_check` is two fields; the orchestrator is a two-step flip + (`open_pr` → `merge_pr`) that **keeps the body** and sets `repo=None`; + no rollback (merge-failure cleans up the unmerged PR + branch). New + `graduate_failed` audit kind; removed the `graduate_repo_*` / + `graduate_rollback` steps. +- `bot.py`: `open_graduation_pr` drops `repo_full` + the "moves to + RFC.md" PR body; deleted `create_rfc_repo_for_graduation`, + `seed_graduated_rfc`, `delete_rfc_repo`. +- Dispatch re-keyed on **meta-residency (`repo IS NULL`)** in + `api_prs.py` + `api_branches.py` (`_is_meta_resident`, `_is_meta_target`, + the cache-refresh dispatch); removed the two `"RFC has no repo"` 409 + guards; `promote-to-branch` now names an active RFC's auto-branch + `edit--` so the shared meta-repo cache can attribute it; + the §9.8 read-only-edit-branch guard scoped to legacy per-repo only; + `pre_graduation_history` scoped to legacy per-repo only. +- `cache.py`: `refresh_meta_branches` includes meta-resident active + RFCs (synthetic main + edit branches). `hygiene.py`: branch-delete + repo resolution keyed on meta-residency. +- `GraduateDialog.jsx` + `api.js`: two-field dialog, two-step stack, no + repo field, no blocking-PR popover. +- **Tests:** rewrote `test_graduation_vertical.py` to the flip model + (happy-path keeps body + no per-repo + no repo audit rows; coexists + with open body-edit PR; open-pr failure leaves super-draft; merge + failure cleans up; edit branch surfaces normally post-graduation); + updated `test_hygiene_vertical.py` + `test_e2e_smoke.py`. **Full + suite: 375 passed.** Frontend builds clean. +- Bumped VERSION + frontend/package.json to **0.31.0**; CHANGELOG entry + with RFC 2119 upgrade steps (incl. the MUST fold-back step). + +### Arc 4 — Release, deploy, RFC-0001 fold-back + +Committed v0.31.0 on the worktree branch. While pushing, +**origin/main had moved** — a parallel session (0042.0) shipped +v0.30.2 (header nav "Philosophy" → "About"), touching VERSION, +package.json, CHANGELOG. Rebased onto the new main; resolved the three +conflicts (kept 0.31.0; CHANGELOG order 0.31.0 → 0.30.2 → 0.30.1). +Re-ran the full backend suite post-rebase: **375 passed**. Pushed +`0c972c8` → origin `main` + tag `v0.31.0` + the **benstull mirror** +(a transient LibreSSL `SSL_ERROR_SYSCALL` on the first origin-main push +needed one retry; the tag + mirror landed first try). + +Bumped the ohm-rfc pin 0.30.2 → 0.31.0 (`69121e6`) — done in an +**isolated ohm-rfc worktree** because the shared checkout was on session +0042's `philosophy/concept-not-word` branch. `flotilla deploy +ohm-rfc-app` → **deploys.id=45**, all 9 steps green (no SSE-keepalive +SIGTERM abort this time), v0.31.0 live + `/api/health` ok. Verified the +dual-capable code still rendered RFC-0001 via the legacy per-repo path +(repo still set, 22KB body from RFC.md). + +Then folded RFC-0001 back (deploy-first ordering kept the live app from +409-ing on a repo-null active): built the meta-only entry with the +rfc-app `entry` serializer (round-trip checked — `repo: null`, state +active, id RFC-0001, 22KB body restored), opened **ohm-meta PR #8** +(branch `fold-human-meta-only`) via the #35 authoring lane, merged it; +updated `rfc-0001-human/README.md` to an archive-notice pointer and +**archived** the repo (`PATCH … {"archived": true}`). The ohm-meta +webhook fired — the live catalog flipped `human` to `repo: None` with +the body served from the meta entry, no reconciler wait needed. + +Updated ROADMAP #36 (struck, meta-only, deploys.id=45) + #33 (added the +ohm-content rename sub-item) in the ohm-rfc worktree, pushed `4526f64`. +Removed both worktrees + branches. + +--- + +## Cut state (end of session) + +| repo | state | +| --- | --- | +| rfc-app | `main` = `0c972c8`, tag **v0.31.0** (origin + benstull mirror) | +| ohm-rfc | `main` = `4526f64`; pin `.rfc-app-version` = **0.31.0**; ROADMAP #36 struck, #33 += rename | +| ohm-meta | `human` = active, **repo: null**, body restored (PR #8 merged); `informed-consent` super-draft | +| wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human | **archived** (README → archive-notice pointer) | +| OHM live | **deploys.id=45, v0.31.0, healthy** | + +| #36 ledger | Status | +| --- | --- | +| #36 RFC topology (meta-only) | ✅ shipped — rfc-app v0.31.0, deploys.id=45 | +| RFC-0001 fold-back | ✅ done — ohm-meta PR #8 + repo archived | + +--- + +## §19.2 / process candidates surfaced + +1. **ohm-meta → ohm-content rename (#33).** The meta-only topology makes + the repo the single content home; the name should follow. Config- + driven (META_REPO overlay), no rfc-app code change. Captured in + ROADMAP #33 + the next-session prompt below. +2. **Authoring-lane token scope.** `ohm-gitea-token` is + `write:repository` — cannot comment on PRs/issues (403, needs + `write:issue`). Document or widen. (Memory written.) +3. **SPEC incidental-reference sweep.** §1 carries a blanket + supersession note for the ~30 incidental "RFC.md / the repo" mentions + in later sections (the editing machinery is unchanged, only the + location collapses). A future pass could rewrite each inline if the + blanket note ever reads as ambiguous. + +--- + +## What lands on the operator's plate + +1. **ROADMAP #33 ohm-content rename** — operator-run ops gesture (gitea + repo rename + META_REPO overlay + webhook + VM meta-content remote + + redeploy). Prompt provided in chat + below. +2. **RFC-0002 graduation is now unblocked** — graduating it is an + in-place flip (no repo). Operator decides when/whether. + +--- + +## Decisions / notes for the record + +- **Deploy ordering:** v0.31.0 is dual-capable (handles both legacy + per-repo actives and meta-only actives), so it is deployed FIRST, then + RFC-0001 is folded back — avoids a window where the live app 409s on a + repo-null active. +- **Authoring-lane runbook gap:** `ohm-gitea-token` is `write:repository` + scope; PR/issue commenting needs `write:issue`. Either widen the scope + or document that the lane can open/merge/close PRs but not comment. +- **#33 follow-up captured:** rename `wiggleverse/ohm-meta → ohm-content` + (rename repo → update `META_REPO` overlay → update the Gitea webhook → + re-point catalog + redeploy). Decided this session; deferred to a #33 + ops session. + +--- + +## Prompt the operator can paste into the next session + +``` +OHM driver session. Reserve your own session ID first +(~/git/ohm-infra/scripts/claim-session-id.sh --start ). +Read ~/git/ohm-infra/SESSION-PROTOCOL.md once at start. + +GOAL: ROADMAP #33 — rename the RFC content repository +wiggleverse/ohm-meta → wiggleverse/ohm-content. The meta-only topology +(#36, rfc-app v0.31.0, session 0041.0) made this repo the single +canonical home of every RFC, so "meta" is now a misnomer and "content" +tells a cleaner deployer story. OPERATIONAL/config move — the framework +references the repo by the config-driven META_REPO name, so NO rfc-app +code change is needed. (SPEC §1 already carries the "- +content" framing as of v0.31.0.) + +PRE-STATE (confirm first): +- OHM live: rfc-app v0.31.0 (deploys.id=45), meta-only. +- RFC-0001 `human` is folded back: ohm-meta/rfcs/human.md has repo:null + + the full body; wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human is archived. Catalog: + human (active, repo None) + informed-consent (super-draft). +- Live META_REPO overlay = "ohm-meta"; gitea org = "wiggleverse". +- Parallel session 0042 was on ohm-rfc branch philosophy/concept-not-word + — ensure it's done before renaming the content repo. + +THE MOVE (in order, verify each; quiet window, no in-flight edit/PR): +1. Rename gitea repo: PATCH /repos/wiggleverse/ohm-meta {"name": + "ohm-content"} (via the #35 authoring lane `api` verb). Gitea keeps + attached webhooks + leaves an old-name redirect — confirm both. +2. flotilla overlay set ohm-rfc-app META_REPO=ohm-content (overlay, + NOT secret set — it's non-secret config). +3. Update flotilla's webhook EXPECTATION in the §13 deployment record + (the #18/v1.3.0 `webhook expect` set names ohm-meta → repoint to + ohm-content), then `flotilla webhook check --org`. +4. Re-point the VM meta-content checkout (PHILOSOPHY_PATH source at + /opt/ohm-rfc-app/meta-content): update its origin remote to + .../ohm-content.git and pull (manual — flotilla deploy doesn't + refresh it). +5. flotilla deploy ohm-rfc-app, then verify: /api/health ok; catalog + lists human (active) + informed-consent (super-draft); a super-draft + body-edit branch+PR round-trip works against the renamed repo. +6. Sweep "ohm-meta" → "ohm-content" doc references (CLAUDE.md, + SESSION-PROTOCOL.md, ROADMAP, deployment record). Strike #33's + ohm-content sub-item. + +GOTCHAS: +- Do NOT rename ben/ohm-rfc (the DEPLOYMENT content repo with the pin + + ROADMAP) — only the RFC framework meta repo ohm-meta → ohm-content. +- Authoring-lane token is write:repository (opens/merges/closes PRs + + PATCHes the repo, but cannot comment — 403; needs write:issue). +- Broader #33 (ohm-infra → ohm-rfc-infra; fold ohm-session-history into + ohm-rfc-infra/sessions/) is a separate multi-repo arc — only take it + on if you intend that scope. + +Context: ohm-rfc/ROADMAP.md #33 + #36; rfc-app SPEC §1/§13.6. Finalize + +publish the transcript last. +``` diff --git a/0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--INPROGRESS.md b/0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--INPROGRESS.md deleted file mode 100644 index b80d9aa..0000000 --- a/0041/SESSION-0041.0-TRANSCRIPT-2026-05-29T05-45--INPROGRESS.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,152 +0,0 @@ -# Session 0041.0 — Transcript - -> Date: 2026-05-29 -> Start: 2026-05-29T05-45 (PST implied) -> Status: **IN PROGRESS** -> -> Goal: Settle ROADMAP #36 — adopt the meta-only RFC repository topology -> (no per-RFC repos; graduation = in-place state flip), revise the -> rfc-app SPEC + code, fold RFC-0001 back into its meta entry, ship -> rfc-app v0.31.0, deploy to OHM. - ---- - -## Plan / TODO - -- [x] Claim session ID (0041). -- [x] Close stale ohm-meta PR #2 (duplicate "Graduate human" PR). -- [x] Read SPEC §1/§3/§13 + map the rfc-app graduation code surface. -- [x] Operator decisions: settle #36 meta-only; fold RFC-0001 back - (single model); reframe SPEC for the "single content repo" deployer - story + track the ohm-meta→ohm-content rename for #33. -- [x] Revise SPEC §1/§2/§3/§4/§9.8/§13 to meta-only (operator signed off - on the diff). -- [x] rfc-app code: collapse graduation to an in-place flip; re-key the - branch/PR/chat dispatch on meta-residency; remove the per-repo - read path / guards; simplify the bot + GraduateDialog. -- [x] Tests green (full suite 375 passed); frontend builds. -- [x] Bump VERSION + package.json + CHANGELOG (v0.31.0). -- [ ] RFC-0001 fold-back content migration (restore body to meta entry, - `repo: null`, archive `wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human`). -- [ ] Commit + tag v0.31.0 + push origin + benstull mirror. -- [ ] Bump ohm-rfc pin to v0.31.0. -- [ ] `flotilla deploy ohm-rfc-app` + verify. -- [ ] Strike ROADMAP #36; capture #33 rename follow-up. -- [ ] Finalize + publish transcript. - ---- - -## Launch prompt - -OHM driver session. Reserve session ID. Context from session 0040.0: -#35 (operator RFC authoring lane) proven; "Informed Consent" super-draft -live; **#36 OPEN + BLOCKING** — decide repo-per-RFC vs. meta-only -(operator leans meta-only); OHM live v0.30.1 (deploys.id=43), rfc-app -main 732b23b; loose end ohm-meta PR #2 (stale graduate-human) open. - ---- - -## Pre-session state - -- OHM live: v0.30.1, healthy (`/api/health` ok). -- rfc-app `main` at `732b23b` (v0.30.1). -- ohm-meta: `human` is **active** (RFC-0001, `repo: - wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human`, graduated 2026-05-26, body stripped to - frontmatter), `informed-consent` is a super-draft. `wiggleverse/rfc-0001-human` - exists with a 22KB `RFC.md`. -- PR #2 was a **duplicate** stale graduation PR (the real graduation - merged 2026-05-26 via another PR); closing it was correct. - ---- - -## Turn-by-turn arc - -### Arc 1 — Orient + operator decisions - -Claimed 0041. Closed ohm-meta PR #2 (the authoring-lane token is -`write:repository`, not `write:issue`, so the explanatory PR comment -got a 403 — closure itself succeeded; **runbook gap noted**: commenting -needs `write:issue` scope). Discovered RFC-0001 is a real graduated -per-repo RFC (22KB RFC.md), which made its fate the pivot for #36. - -Operator decisions (via AskUserQuestion): -1. **Settle #36 meta-only** (full code + deploy, not SPEC-only). -2. **Fold RFC-0001 back** to a single meta-only model (restore body to - the meta entry, archive the repo, delete the per-repo read path) — - rather than grandfathering it as a dual path. -3. **Reframe the SPEC** for the "single content repository" deployer - story (a framework-level win, not just OHM), keep `META_REPO` config - term stable, and **track the concrete `ohm-meta → ohm-content` - rename as a #33 follow-up** (do NOT rename this session). - -### Arc 2 — SPEC revision (signed off) - -Rewrote SPEC §1 (topology: one meta repo, no per-RFC repos, + a boxed -supersession note + deployer-facing "content repository" framing), §2 -(`repo:` always-null, README index, body-migration note), §3 (active = -in-place state), §3.2, §4 (cache/reconciler), §9.8 (the four per-repo -handoff frictions struck through), and §13 in full (retitled "in -place"; §13.2 two-field dialog, no repo name, no open-PR precondition; -§13.3 "The flip" = single open+merge PR, body kept, no transaction/no -rollback, old sequence struck through; §13.4 nothing moves; §13.5 -reversal softened; new §13.6 RFC-0001 fold-back migration record). -Operator approved the diff as the contract. - -### Arc 3 — rfc-app code (meta-only) - -- `api_graduation.py` rewritten: `GraduateBody` drops `repo_name`; - `graduate_check` is two fields; the orchestrator is a two-step flip - (`open_pr` → `merge_pr`) that **keeps the body** and sets `repo=None`; - no rollback (merge-failure cleans up the unmerged PR + branch). New - `graduate_failed` audit kind; removed the `graduate_repo_*` / - `graduate_rollback` steps. -- `bot.py`: `open_graduation_pr` drops `repo_full` + the "moves to - RFC.md" PR body; deleted `create_rfc_repo_for_graduation`, - `seed_graduated_rfc`, `delete_rfc_repo`. -- Dispatch re-keyed on **meta-residency (`repo IS NULL`)** in - `api_prs.py` + `api_branches.py` (`_is_meta_resident`, `_is_meta_target`, - the cache-refresh dispatch); removed the two `"RFC has no repo"` 409 - guards; `promote-to-branch` now names an active RFC's auto-branch - `edit--` so the shared meta-repo cache can attribute it; - the §9.8 read-only-edit-branch guard scoped to legacy per-repo only; - `pre_graduation_history` scoped to legacy per-repo only. -- `cache.py`: `refresh_meta_branches` includes meta-resident active - RFCs (synthetic main + edit branches). `hygiene.py`: branch-delete - repo resolution keyed on meta-residency. -- `GraduateDialog.jsx` + `api.js`: two-field dialog, two-step stack, no - repo field, no blocking-PR popover. -- **Tests:** rewrote `test_graduation_vertical.py` to the flip model - (happy-path keeps body + no per-repo + no repo audit rows; coexists - with open body-edit PR; open-pr failure leaves super-draft; merge - failure cleans up; edit branch surfaces normally post-graduation); - updated `test_hygiene_vertical.py` + `test_e2e_smoke.py`. **Full - suite: 375 passed.** Frontend builds clean. -- Bumped VERSION + frontend/package.json to **0.31.0**; CHANGELOG entry - with RFC 2119 upgrade steps (incl. the MUST fold-back step). - -### Arc 4 — (in progress) content migration + release + deploy - -_To be filled in: RFC-0001 fold-back, tag/push, pin bump, deploy, -verify._ - ---- - -## Decisions / notes for the record - -- **Deploy ordering:** v0.31.0 is dual-capable (handles both legacy - per-repo actives and meta-only actives), so it is deployed FIRST, then - RFC-0001 is folded back — avoids a window where the live app 409s on a - repo-null active. -- **Authoring-lane runbook gap:** `ohm-gitea-token` is `write:repository` - scope; PR/issue commenting needs `write:issue`. Either widen the scope - or document that the lane can open/merge/close PRs but not comment. -- **#33 follow-up captured:** rename `wiggleverse/ohm-meta → ohm-content` - (rename repo → update `META_REPO` overlay → update the Gitea webhook → - re-point catalog + redeploy). Decided this session; deferred to a #33 - ops session. - ---- - -## Prompt the operator can paste into the next session - -_(to be finalized at session end)_