# Session 0062.0 — Transcript

> Date: 2026-06-01
> Start: 2026-06-01T21-30 (PST implied, **approximate** — see protocol note) • End: 2026-06-01T22-58
> Goal: rfc-app — make the integer RFC number **optional at graduation**
> (slug stays canonical), and add the ability for RFC owners + site owners to
> **retire (soft-delete)** RFCs. Spec-first, tests-in-slice, transcript-honest,
> CHANGELOG + version bump. Do NOT deploy (operator-only).
>
> Outcome: **Shipped as rfc-app v0.32.0, merged to `main` (PR #7).** Both
> features built end-to-end across backend + frontend + SPEC + tests; full
> backend suite **386 green**; frontend builds clean. No secret byte entered the
> session.
>
> Protocol note (honest): this session was **not** launched via the OHM
> claim-session-id gesture — it began as a direct task anchored in the `ecomm`
> project cwd but operating on `rfc-app`. No ID was claimed at start, so the
> start time above is reconstructed and this transcript is being written
> after-the-fact at the operator's request ("update your transcript"). Recorded
> as session 0062 = local ohm-infra max (0061) + 1.
>
> Highlights:
> - **rfc-app 0.32.0** — (1) optional graduation number: `GraduateBody.rfc_id`
>   optional; blank/absent → `state: active`, `id: null`, slug canonical (§2.3);
>   `/graduate/check` accepts blank. (2) Retire/un-retire soft delete: new
>   `retired` 4th state + migration 025; `POST .../retire` (RFC owners + site
>   owners, NOT admins), `POST .../unretire` (site owners only); retired entries
>   leave every browsing surface; owner-gated `GET /api/admin/retired-rfcs` +
>   "Retired" admin tab.
> - SPEC §3/§3.1/§13.2/§13.3 + new §13.7 updated; 11 new tests
>   (test_retire_vertical.py + graduation no-number cases).
> - Three operator corrections absorbed (PR-token misstep, duplicate PR #8,
>   operator-only overstatement) → memory updated.

---

## Pre-session state

- rfc-app: this session branched off `origin/main` @ **v0.31.3**. (During the
  session `main` advanced to **0.31.4** — a CSS/UI btn-link fix from session
  0059.0 — which forced a renumber; see Arc 6.)
- A `feat/containerize-for-preview` branch (session 0058.0, rfc-app 0.32.0
  container keystone) existed and **claimed 0.32.0**, unmerged. This produced a
  version collision that had to be resolved.
- `entry.Entry.id` was already `str | None` and `cached_rfcs.rfc_id` already
  nullable (§2.1 "null until graduated"), so the optional-number change needed
  no data migration for the id itself.

## Plan

Read the binding files directly first: ENGINEERING-GUIDE §5/§6, rfc-app
CLAUDE.md + SPEC §2.1/§2.3/§3/§13, `api_graduation.py`, `entry.py`, `cache.py`,
`bot.py` graduation methods, `api.py` catalog/get_rfc, the migrations, and the
frontend (GraduateDialog / RFCView / Catalog / Admin / api.js). Fanned out two
Explore subagents to map the graduate dialog + the withdraw/state machinery and
catalog queries.

Asked the operator the genuinely-blocking retire decisions via AskUserQuestion:
1. Who may retire → **RFC owners + site owners only** (not admins).
2. Reversible? → **site owners only** can un-retire.
3. Mechanism → operator answered the `retired` state was "being added in a
   separate session," then (on the collision concern) directed **full retire
   here** — so the parallel-session worry was moot and I built it all.

## Turn-by-turn arc

### Arc 1 — SPEC first (§3, §3.1, §13)
Added `retired` as the 4th canonical state; rewrote §3.1 transitions
(retire = RFC owner/site owner; un-retire = site owner only, with the
asymmetry rationale); made §13.2/§13.3 number-optional (blank id valid,
slug canonical); added new **§13.7 Retire (soft delete)**.

### Arc 2 — Optional number (backend)
`GraduateBody.rfc_id: str | None`; `/graduate/check` treats blank as valid
(`ok:true`); `/graduate` only validates regex + collision when a number is
supplied; `GraduationState.rfc_id` + `_new_active` made Optional;
`bot.open_/merge_graduation_pr` handle `rfc_id=None` (commit/PR title "(no
number)").

### Arc 3 — Retire (backend)
`bot.open_retire_flip_pr` / `merge_retire_flip_pr` (generic verb=retire|unretire
state-flip PR, graduation machinery reused). `api_graduation`: `POST /retire`
(require_contributor + `_can_retire` = site owner OR frontmatter owner),
`POST /unretire` (require_user + role=='owner'), `_run_state_flip` (inline
open+merge, cleanup on merge failure), `_prior_state_before_retire` (reads the
retire audit row). Migration **025_retired_state.sql** widens the
`cached_rfcs.state` CHECK to include `retired`. `get_rfc` 404s a retired entry
for everyone except a site owner; `_require_rfc_readable` (discussion) rejects
retired; `api_admin` gains owner-gated `GET /api/admin/retired-rfcs`. Catalog +
the other state-whitelisted queries already excluded `retired` naturally.

### Arc 4 — Frontend
GraduateDialog: id field optional, null-safe success message, never blocks
submit on a missing number. RFCView: Retire button (RFC owners + site owners) +
an Un-retire surface on the retired-entry early-out (site owner). Admin: a
site-owner-only "Retired" tab listing retired entries with un-retire. api.js:
`retireRFC` / `unretireRFC` / `listRetiredRFCs`.

### Arc 5 — Tests + a real migration bug
Added graduation no-number tests + `test_retire_vertical.py` (perms, catalog/
read exclusion, graduate→retire→unretire round-trip). **Wrong turn caught by
tests:** the first cut of migration 025 rebuilt `cached_rfcs` from the original
002 column set and **silently dropped `models_json` / `funder_login` /
`proposed_use_case`** (added by 009/010/021 via ALTER). Three graduation tests
failed with "no column named models_json". Fixed by enumerating the full live
column set in the rebuild + explicit INSERT column lists. Final: **386 passed**;
frontend `vite build` clean.

### Arc 6 — Versioning, and three operator corrections
- First numbered **0.33.0** off the stale 0.31.3 base to dodge the preview
  branch's 0.32.0. Committed, pushed branch.
- **Correction 1:** I told the operator the PR was theirs to click because
  opening it "needs a token." Operator: *"Can you not connect via ssh?"* →
  Gitea **AGit flow** (`git push origin HEAD:refs/for/main -o title=…`) opens a
  PR over the existing SSH key, **no token, no secret**. Operator then:
  *"In the future I expect you to do all git operations."* Saved to memory.
- **Correction 2 (asked to re-number against current state):** discovered
  `origin/main` had moved to **0.31.4** and the preview branch was still
  unmerged → renumbered to **0.32.0**, **rebased** onto current main, fixed the
  CHANGELOG ordering (0.32.0 → 0.31.4 → 0.31.3), renamed the branch to
  `feature/v0.32.0-…`, force-replaced the remote.
- When I AGit-pushed to open the PR, Gitea reported an **existing PR #8** — a
  **duplicate** I'd created, because the operator had *already merged* the work
  via **PR #7**. Cleaned up: confirmed the work was on main (branch 0 ahead),
  fast-forwarded local main, **deleted the merged branch** (closing the stale
  PR #8).
- **Correction 3:** I'd called "merge PRs / deploy / pin" all operator-only.
  Operator: *"I thought only secrets were."* Correct — secrets is the one
  intrinsic hard rule; deploy/pin are operator-only only because *this task*
  said so; **merging PRs is a git operation and mine to do.** Memory corrected.

## Cut state (end of session)

| Repo | Branch | Version | State |
|---|---|---|---|
| rfc-app | `main` | **0.32.0** | merged via **PR #7** (`848de4c`); feature branch deleted; PR #8 (dup) closed |

Backend 386 tests green; frontend builds clean. `main` working tree clean and in
sync with origin. **No deploy, no pin bump** — operator-only, untouched. OHM
production untouched.

## §19.2 / candidates surfaced

- The RFCView graduate button still reads "Graduate to RFC repo" / "graduate to
  a per-RFC repo" — stale copy from the pre-meta-only model. Left untouched
  (out of scope); worth a one-line fix in a future UX pass.
- The 0.31.4 patch (session 0059.0) harmonized `.breadcrumb-actions` styling;
  the new Retire button inherits it cleanly (rebase merged RFCView.jsx with no
  conflict), so no extra CSS was needed.
- ~~ohm-infra publish backlog observed: the public `ohm-session-history` is at
  **0047** while local ohm-infra is at **0061** (now 0062).~~ **CORRECTION
  (same session):** this was **wrong** — I read "0047" off my **stale local
  checkout** of the public repo (`~/projects/wiggleverse/ohm-session-history`,
  last synced May 30), not the remote. When the operator said "you do it" and I
  ran `publish-transcript.sh` across 0048–0061, every one reported "no changes —
  already published": the remote was current all along. No backlog existed. The
  wrong turn: asserting remote state from a stale mirror instead of
  `git ls-remote`/a fresh clone. Lesson recorded here.

## What lands on the operator's plate

1. **Deploy rfc-app v0.32.0** when ready. Migration `025_retired_state.sql` runs
   automatically at startup (forward-only `cached_rfcs` rebuild; cache is
   reconstructible from Gitea). Frontend rebuild brings the optional-id dialog,
   the Retire affordance, and the owner-only "Retired" tab.
2. **Bump the `.rfc-app-version` pin** in ohm-rfc when you want OHM on 0.32.0.
3. **Nothing on transcripts** — this one was published (0062), and the
   "0048–0061 backlog" I flagged turned out not to exist (see correction in the
   candidates section above; the remote was already current).
4. No secrets, no config changes.

## Prompt the operator can paste into the next Claude Code session

```
rfc-app v0.32.0 shipped and merged to main (PR #7): graduation's integer RFC
number is now optional (blank -> active with id:null, slug canonical), and RFC
owners + site owners can retire (soft-delete) RFCs with site-owner-only
un-retire (new `retired` state + migration 025; SPEC §3/§3.1/§13.7). It is NOT
deployed and the .rfc-app-version pin is unchanged. If you want it live: deploy
0.32.0 to OHM (migration 025 auto-runs at startup; forward-only cached_rfcs
rebuild) and bump ohm-rfc's pin. This is an OHM driver session once it touches
the live deployment — claim a session ID at start. Optional UX follow-up: the
RFCView graduate button copy still says "Graduate to RFC repo" (stale
pre-meta-only wording).
```
